Sale by Auction. Miscellaneous Books, MSS., Parchment Deeds, &c. MESSRS. HODGSON & CO. will SELL by NOTES AND QUERIES is published on FRIDAY MORNING at 10 o'clock. WEDNESDAY, January 15, and Following Day, at 1 o'clock, MI NOTES AND QUERIES.-The SUBSCRIPTION AUCTION, at their Rooms, 115, Chancery Lane, W.C.. on CELLANEOUS BOOKS, including the Library of the late W. T. BROWNE (of Chetham's Library, Manchester), sold by order of the Executor, comprising a Collection of Books on Calligraphy, Penmanship, Secret Writing, and Shorthand-Hasted's History of Kent, 12 vols., with the Plates to the Folio Edition-Books with Coloured Plates-First Editions - Coloured Caricatures and Books on the Caricaturists-Scrap Books, &c.; also an EXTENSIVE COLLECTION OF SIXTEENTH, SEVENTEENTH, AND EIGHTEENTH CEN TURY DEEDS on Parchment, relating to Property in various English Counties-M8S. of Antiquarian and Genealogical InterestLetters and Documents relating to America. Catalogues on application. THE AUTHOR'S HAIRLESS PAPER-PAD (The LEADENHALL PRESS, Ltd., Publishers and Printers, 29-47, GARDEN ROW, ST. GEORGE'S ROAD, SOUTHWARK, 8.E.) Contains hairless paper, over which the pen slips with perfect freedom. Sixpence each. 58 per dozen, ruled or plain. New Pocket size, 88. per dozen, ruled or plain. STICKPHAST is a clean white Paste, and not a messy liquid. WANTED to BUY, OLD DEEDS, DOCU MENTS, LEASES, &c., relating to City Property, neighbourhood of Thames Street and London Bridge.-REGINALD JACOBS, 6, Templars Avenue, Golder's Green, London. to NOTES AND QUERIES free by post is 58. 2d. for Three Months: 108. 3d. for Six Months; or 208. 6d. for Twelve Months, including the volume Index. J. EDWARD FRANCIS, Notes and Queries Office, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.C. JOHN O. FRANCIS and J. EDWARD FRANCIS, Notes and Queries Office, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E.O. IN MEMORIALS "CULN" BRASS AND BRONZE, MARBLE AND ALABASTER. THE CLIQUE: GAWTHORP & SONS, The Antiquarian Bookseller's Weekly. Established 1890. ISSUED SATURDAYS. "OUT OF PRINT." When your bookseller gives you that reply, or you want a SCARCE BOOK, tell him to advertise in THE CLIQUE (the ONLY organ of the Antiquarian Book-Trade) and he is SURE TO GET IT. Advertisements inserted for booksellers only. The readers of THE CLIQUE hold between them SEVENTY MILLION VOLUMES, so you see how certain you are to get the ONE VOLUME you want. THE CLIQUE is issued to booksellers only, 88. 8d. per annum, expiring December 31. Subscribers joining now should remit at the rate of 2d. per week till December 31, 1915. All the eminent booksellers of the world advertise in THE CLIQUE. THE CLIQUE, LTD., 30, RIVERCOURT ROAD, W. 16, LONG ACRe, london, W.C. (Partners: T. G. & W. E. GAWTHORP, F.S.A.Scot.) EXPERTS IN REPAIRING ANCIENT BRASSES AND DESIGNERS OF MEMORIALS TO MANY WORTHIES OF THE LAST FOUR CENTURIES, By Appointment to H.M. KING GEORGE V. AUTHORIZED TO BE USED BY BRITISH SUBJECTS. THE NATIONAL FLAG, LONDON, SATURDAY, JANUARY 2, 1915. CONTENTS.-No. 262. NOTES:-An Analogy to Sir Thomas Browne, 1-The M.P.-Williamson of Annan, 9. - Journal'-'Winter's Pie '-'The Cornhill.' Notes. them a deposit-a "great lump of an heavy Upon exploring further, it was found that REPLIES:-Lieut. Col. Thomas Carteret Hardy, 10-The AN ANALOGY TO SIR THOMAS For those attracted by the works of Sir This is done because the Mississippi River copy in the Grenville Library at the British "A Conference about the next succession to the succession. To my mind the walls discovered in Brampton correspond to the walls at present used in our own country, although I admit this holds true in only a rough way. Should I be assuming too much were I to say that these Brampton walls were once above ground, or at least in some cave or grotto? Their depth in the earth upon discovery might be due to gradual changes that had taken place in the topography and physio- 66 Whereunto is also added a new and perfect graphy of the neighbourhood. As to any arbor or genealogie of the descents of all the doubt that might arise concerning the kings and princes of England from the Conquest survival of the brick walls through so many down to this day, whereby each man's pretence centuries without wearing away and finally ourable the Earle of Essex, of her Majesties is made more plaine. Directed to the right disappearing, I might offer as an example privie councell & of the noble order of the Garter. the artificial mounds and walls lately Published by R. Doleman. Imprinted at N. brought to light in North America. These with License. MDXCIIII. were built during the Pleistocene Age. Or if the Brampton burial walls were constructed in a cave, they very probably were not submerged in earth until recent times, when the roof of the cave fell in. Whether the walls were built in a cave or on the surface of the ground, the important fact is that their peculiar construction, in coincidence with the method of burial in New Orleans, brings forth the idea of the topographical changes that have occurred in England. Was the region around Brampton at one time in the vicinity of a large river, or did the sea approach close thereto, making the wall method of burial compulsory? It is for those best fitted in this line of research to determine. KENNETH M. LEWIS. Short Hills, New Jersey, U.S. PUBLISHED on 3 Feb., 1648, nearly a whole year before the King was beheaded, and professing (inferentially) to be a report of a conference between the Lords and the Co nmons about taking action against the King, this book is the most important fraud in English history. It is usually_catalogued to the Jesuit Father Robert Persons, or Parsons, who, or Verstegan, wrote the original book, of which this was a piracy. The original is a rare work, owing to the steps taken to suppress it when it was published. The following is the title of the The origin and history of this book have been exhaustively treated by the Rev. J. H. Pollen, S.J., in a paper entitled 'The Question of Queen Elizabeth's Successor,' printed in The Month for May, 1903. Father Pollen seemed to incline to the view that its printer, Verstegan, poet and antiquary, was its author, rather than Father Persons, though I understand that he has since somewhat modified his opinion. The work is a learned one, but met, and still meets, with condemnation on all sides, both Catholic and Protestant. What is quite certain is that no controversial work ever had a stranger after-history. The full title of Walker's piracy deserves citation, if only to show how he succeeded in changing the original object of the book : "Severall Speeches delivered at a Conference concerning the power of Parliament to proceed against their King for misgovernment. "In which is stated : "I. That government by blood is not by Law of Nature or divine, but only by human and positive laws of every particular Commonwealth, and may upon just causes be altered. 66 II. The particular forme of monarchies and kings, and yet how divers of them have been "IV. The lawfulnesse of proceeding against admitting to their authority & the othes [sic] "V. The coronation of Princes and manner of "VI. What is due to onely succession by birth and by what interest or right an heire apparent hath in the Crown before he is crowned or admitted by the Commonwealth. And how justly he may be put back if he have not the parts requisite. "VII. How the next in succession by propinquity of blood have often times been put back by the Commonwealth and others further off admitted in their places, even in those kingdomes where succession prevaileth, with many examples of the kingdomes of Israel and Spaine. "VIII. Divers other examples out of the States of France and England, for proofe that the next in blood are sometimes put back from succession, and how God hath approved the same with good successe. "IX. What are the principall points which a Commonwealth ought to respect in admitting, or excluding their King; wherein is handled largely also of the diversity of religions and other such There was not the slightest hint in this book of its origin, and to all appearance it was a new work. Walker advertised it as follows: Perfect Occurrences, 21-28 Jan., 1647/8 (p. 393): Concerning these nicities [sic] there is a booke in the presse of diverse speeches at a conference, concerning the power of the Parliament in relation to the King, which will within few dayes be published." Perfect Occurrences, 28 Jan.-4 Feb., 1647/8 (p. 402):- Thursday, Feb. 3. His Majesty is very melancholy. The speeches at a conference came abroad this day in print, concerning the King." Anthony à Wood in his Life of Persons draws attention to this piracy, and says as follows ('Athenæ,' ii. 71): "Dr. Barlow's note [in the Bodleian copy] is this, in a spare leaf before the title: 'This base and treacherous pamphlet is, verbatim, the first part of Francis Doleman [Parsons was the man under that name] touching succession to the Crown. These nine speeches, as here they call them, are the nine chapters in Doleman. And this was printed at the charge of the Parliament, 30 pound being paid to the printer, "in perpetuam eorum infamiam." See the collection of His Majesties gracious messages for peace, p. 125, 120. The messages were collected and printed with observations upon them by Mr. Simons. The said traiterous pamphlet [' Several Speeches'] was put out by Walker, an ironmonger (from that he came to be a cowherd) [?]. When the King came into London about the five members he threw into his coach a traiterous pamphlet, call'd "To thy tents, O Israel" (vid. Lambert Wood's History). He afterwards writ the Perfect Occurrences, and now [1649] is made a minister by the Presbyterians [?]. Mr. Darby, a They [the Parliament] pretended great enmity unto popish doctrine and tenents, and episcopacy was pull'd down out of zeale against With popery (as if that had been a friend to it). what clamours did they represent to the people Secretary Windebank's intercourse with Jesuits and popish priests. And yet these very men have permitted Mabbot (the allowed broker of all these venomous scribblings) to authorise the printing a book of Parsons the jesuite, full of the most popish and treasonable positions that ever were vented, for very good doctrine. Nay, more then this; have they not contributed 301. when, after its publication, it was told them by towards the charge of printing the same, and some that the said booke had been condemned by Parliament in the 35 of Queen Elizabeth and that the printer thereof was drawn, hang'd and quarter'd for the same [?], and that it was then enacted that whosoever should have it in their house should be guilty of High Treason. When all this was related to some of the Committee of Examinations, did they not stop their ears at it ? Their own consciences know all this to be true, and that we are able to prove it before the world. Yet these be the men, forsooth, that hate Popery. "This popish booke that we speak of was first published anno 1594, under the name of Dolman, and intituled A Conference about the succession of the Crowne.' It consists of two partes, whereof the first conteines the discourse of a civill lawyerHow and in what manner propinquity of blood is. to be preferred. It is divided into nine chapters, all which this blessed reforming Parliament hath now published under the title of Severall Speeches,' &c. They were all answered (as they are in the Jesuites book) by Sir John Haward [Hayward], Doctor of the Civil Law, in the year 1603, and dedicated to King James, which answer is common in booksellers' shops, still to be sold. Now there is no difference betwixt this book published by this Parliament and that of the jesuite condemned by that other an. 35 Eliz. but onely this, when the jesuit mentions the apostles he adds the word 'Saint' to their names, 'S. John. S. James. S. Peter,' which the author of this new edition leaves out, and saies plain John, James and Peter. And perhaps in some places the word Parliament is put instead of the word Pope or People." Nay the variation is so little that it speaks the publisher a very weak man, and those that set him on the work none of the wisest in employing so simple an animal in a businesse of so great concernment; we shall instance but in one passage. "Old Dolman, or Parsons, had said in the year 1594 that many were then living who had seen the severall coronations of King Edw. the 6, Queen Mary, and Queen Eliz. and could witnesse, &c. Now our young Dolman, or Walker, for that is the wiseman's name, supposing that all these people were alive still that were old men 54 years agoe, like a true transcriber affirmeth confidently, without the variation of a letter, in pag 43 of his addition, that many are yet living in England that have seen the severall coronations of King Edw. the 6, Queen Mary and Queen Eliz., to which he also addeth King James and King Charls, because they were crowned since. And this, we confesse, is new in him.' There is a great deal of comment on this book in Prynne's Speech' of 4 Dec., 1648, but I do not set it out because Prynne does not mention Walker's name. The Man in the Moon for 27 June-4 July, 1649, says that Cromwell The motive of this and of his attempt to Finally, Father Persons's unlucky book (To be continued.) A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF THOMAS "hired that factotum of villainous impostur- 10. (b) SEVERALL SPEECHES,' &c. And HOLCROFT. 11 S. x. 1, 43, 83, 122, 163, 205, 244, ་ 'Indian Exiles.' 1798. [Never published.] Indian in England,' which has employed me five |