Obrazy na stronie
PDF
ePub

122

British Association for the Advancement of Science.

gous behaviour of the glycolate, when it is treated in succession with one and afterwards with another molecule of perbromide, and whereby it becomes converted first of all into oxyglycolyl-bromide,

H2O2.

Fo202,2F002Bг,

and subsequently into bromo-glycolyl-bromide,Fo2Bг2,2 FOO2Br,

I proceed upon the hypothesis that the product of the action of the first molecule of perbromide on the glyoxylate is the dioxyglycolyl-bromide, as expressed by the formula

H2O2.

Fo202,2F004Br,

where the molecular changes consist in the replacement by bromine of that particular hydroxyl molecule which belongs to the oxyformate of water group; again, that the product of the action of a second molecule of perbromide on the latter derivative-namely, the abovementioned bromoxyglycolyl-bromide-is expressed by the formula Fo2Br2,2F0O4Br, where the molecular changes consist in the replacement by bromine of that particular hydroxyl molecule which belongs to the colligated formylic alcohol group. But as regards the mode of formation of the third derivative, since, as our formula implies, there is no more hydroxyl to replace, it becomes manifest that the reaction must of necessity take a different course. This course, I venture to say, will consist in the previous conversion of the bromoxyglycolylbromide into the isomeric dibromacetate

[blocks in formation]

To the Editor of the Chemical News. SIR,-In the CHEMICAL NEWs (vol. xxxiv., p. 94) there is a short notice of a paper by M. H. Ballmann on the

{CHEMICAL NEWS,

Sept. 15, 1876.

determidation of lithium by diluting a solution of the metal till a drop, when ignited, ceases to give the chracteristic spectrum. Two or three months ago I made a series of experiments with potassium and the alkaline earths, with the idea of estimating them in solution, by diluting till a measured quantity, generally o'3 c.c., introduced into the flame, ceased to give the most characteristic line of the metal employed. I attached to platinum wires pellets of cotton-wool, or filter papers folded as if for burning, which were made to absorb the quantity of solution, then introduced into the edge of the Bunsen flame. After the drying and burning of the combustible matter, the ash, which is left in the state of a fine network impregnated thoroughly with the salt introduced, gets strongly ignited, and gives the desired spectrum. I found, however, that by diluting the spectra lost their brilliancy so imperceptibly that it was very difficult to fix the point at which they disappeared, especially so with the alkaline earths. It is possible thus to estimate the amount of potassium in a solution, the error allowed being about ten times the quantity of metal to be estimated. I also tried diluting the solution till the line was equal in intensity to that produced by the ignition of a measured quantity of a very dilute solution of the metal of known strength, but met with no better success.

The results of these experiments, and the strain upon the eyes, produced by repeatedly looking attentively for a very faint line, or by looking for a line which you think ought to appear, induced me to give up this method of experimenting.

I would add that a filter paper (as before described) with so much solution of potassic chloride as contained 0'0000006 grm. of metal, when ignited gave the Ka line distinctly. Roscoe gives o'00000032 grm. of potassium as the minimum observable quantity; but by the nature of his experiment that quantity was introduced every second, whereas in the other case the minute portion was introduced once for all.-I am, &c., HENRY C. JONES.

Highbury, September 4, 1876.

MISCELLANEOUS.

Association for the

British Advancement of Science. The meeting of the British Association for 1877 will be held at Plymouth, and will commence on the 15th August. Dr. Allen Thomson, F.R.S., has been nominated President-elect, and the Vice-Presidents chosen are the Earl of Mount Edgecumbe, the Earl of Devon, Lord Blackford, W. Spottiswoode, F.R.S., W. Froude, F.R.S., and C. Spence Bate, F.R.S. The meeting for 1878 will be held at Dublin. The following is a complete list of the papers brought before the Chemical Science Section of the Glasgow Meeting, under the Presidency of Mr. W. H. Perkin, F.R.S.; they will be published CHEMICAL NEWS:in full or in abstract, according to their importance, in the

:

[blocks in formation]

CHEMICAL NEWS,}

Sept. 15, 1876.

British Association for the Advancement of Science.

F. H. T. Allan.-On a Safe and Rapid Evaporating Pan.
Professor Thorpe, F.R.S.-Report on Specific Volumes of
Liquids.

Dr. Atkinson.-Report of Committee for the purpose of
Collecting and Suggesting Subjects for Chemical
Researches.

Walter Weldon.-On the Means of Suppressing Alkali
Waste.

Dr. Macvicar, F.R.S.E.-On the Possible Genesis of the
Chemical Elements out of a Homogeneous Cosmic
Gas or Common Vapour of Matter.

7. Emerson Reynolds, M.D.-On Glucinum: its Atomic
Weight and Specific Heat.

G. Johnstone Stoney, F.R.S.-On the Atomicity of Oxygen

and on the Constitution of Basic Salts. E. H. W. Biggs.-On a New Voltaic Battery. W. H. Perkin, F.R.S.-On New Anthracen Compounds. 7. B. Brown.-On Anthracen Testing. Professor Guthrie, F.R.S.-On Solid Water. Dr. C. R. A. Wright.-On the Alkaloids of the Aconites.

On New Cotarnine Derivatives.

C. T. Kingzett. On the Oxidation of Terpenes. Part IV. Professor Crum Brown.-On the Action of Pentachloride of Phosphorus on Turpentine.

A. C. Letts. On Two New Hydrocarbons from Turpen

tine.

J. V. Buchanan.-On some Instruments Used in the
Challenger."

66

Professor Gladstone, F.R.S.-The Influence of Condition and Quantity of the Negative Element on the Action of the Copper-Zinc Couple.

W. N. Hartley. On the Critical Point of Liquid

bonic Acid in Minerals.

123

Professor Green, "Geological Features of the neighbourhood of Leeds."

G. Dove, jun,, "The North Lincolnshire Iron District."
Henry Kirk, "Some Features of Revolving Puddling
Furnaces and their Products."

Bashley Britten, "Glass from Blast-Furnace Slag."
R. Howson, "On Welding Iron."

G. J. Snelus, "Further Information as to the use of
Molten Iron direct from the Blast Furnace." (Discussion.)
John Jones, "Technical Education in connection with
the Iron Trade."

"Chymistry" and Force.-Professor Tait, in his discourse a few nights ago upon "Force," instanced as one of the things that force cannot accomplish the inability of the Times to make scientific men spell "chemist" with a "y." Those who have remarked the persistency with which the Times adheres to "chymist," may have reflected on hearing this that forces in this respect are evenly matched, and that if the journal cannot coerce men of science, they in turn are powerless to alter the practice of the journal. Professor Tait, however, has succeeded where the combined forces of chemists and grammarians have failed. The Times reported his speech, illustration. The illustration would have been fruitless and his speech would have been incomplete without his unless chemist was spelt with an "e," and with an "e" accordingly the Times spells it, for the first time, probably, within the memory of man. It is true that the offending orthography appears within inverted commas,

but the fact remains, nevertheless, that Professor Tait has Car-developed a force to which the leading journal has succumbed. He has compelled the Times to spell chymist" with an “e.”—Glasgow News.

R. D. Silva. On the Action of Hydriodic Acid on Mixed
Ethers of the General Formula CnH2n+10.CH3.
Dr. Cameron.-On Ammonic Seleniocyanide.

7. A. R. Newlands.-On the Alum Process in Sugar
Refining.

E. M. Dixon.-On an Apparatus for the Analysis of Im-
purities in the Atmosphere.

W. Henderson.-History of Copper Extraction in the Wet
Way.

7. Mactear.-Soda Manufacture.

E. C. C. Stanford.-Iodine and Associated Products.
J. Dunnachie.-Fire-Brick, &c.

T. L. Patterson.-Sugar.

D. Swan.-Zinc.

7. Macrobarts.-Dynamite.

F. Ward.-On the Prevention of Fraudulent Alterations

in Cheques, &c.

Anderson Smith.-On Sodium.

M. M. P. Muir.-On the Action of Dilute Saline Solu

tions on Lead.-On some Compounds of Bismuth.

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small]

F. W. HART, Manufacturer and Dealer in

Apparatus and Chemicals for Scientific Pursuits. Labora tory Fitter and Furnisher. Photographic Apparatus and Materials. 8, KINGSLAND GREEN (West SIDE), LONDON.

Prof. Dewar. Transformation of Chinoline into Aniline. Classes for the UNIVERSITY of LONDON.

W. A. Tilden, D.Sc.-On the Nitroso Derivatives of the
Terpenes. Preliminary note on a new Isopurpurine.
W. Dittmar.-On the Proximate Analysis of Coal Gas.
-Remarks on Reboul's paper on Pyro-Tartaric Acid.
W. Thomson, F.R.S.E.-On the Action of different Fatty
Oils upon Copper.-On the Growth of Mildew on
Grey Cloth.

A. Fergusson. -White Lead.

Col. Hope, V.C.-On the Purification of the Clyde.
W. C. Sillar.-On the Utilisation of Sewage.

MATRICULATION EXAMINATION.

CLASSES are held at St. Bartholomew's Hospital in each year, for the convenience of gentlemen who are preparing for the Matricu lation Examination at the University of London-from October to January and from March to June.

1. Classics, French-Malcolm Laing, M.A., Trin. Coll., Camb. 2. English, Modern Geography, and English History-W. J. Craig, M.A., Trin. Coll., Dublin.

3. Mathematics and Natural Philosophy-The Rev. J. T. Bell, M.A., late Fellow of St. Catherine's Coll., Camb.

4. Chemistry-T. Eltoft, F.C.S.

Fee for the Course of Three Months, £10 10s. The Class is not

Rev. R. Thomson.-The Prevention of the Pollution of confined to Students of the Hospital.
Rivers.

The total number of tickets sold during the Meeting was 2731. Of these 211 were to old life members, 31 to new life members, 318 to old annual members, 208 to new annual members, 1243 to associates, 696 to ladies, and 24 to foreign members. The total amount of receipts up to Tuesday evening was £2983.

Iron and Steel Institute.-A meeting of the Iron and Steel Institute will be held at Leeds on the 19th, 20th, 21st, and 22nd inst. The following is a list of papers and subjects for discussion :—

PRELIMINARY SCIENTIFIC EXAMINATION.

A Class in the subjects required for the Preliminary Scientific Examination is held from January to July, and includes all the subjects required, as follows:

Chemistry-H. E. Armstrong, Ph.D., F.R.S.

Botany-The Rev. G. Henslow, M.A. Cantab., Lecturer on Botany

to the Hospital.

Zoology and Comparative Anatomy-Norman Moore, M.D. Cantab., Lecturer on Comparative Anatomy to the Hospital.

Mechanical and Natural Philosophy-W. Graham, M.A., Trin. Coll., Dub., Demonstrator of Mechanical and Natural Philosophy to the Hospital. Fee to Students of the Hospital, £8 8s.; to others, £10 10s.; fee for any single subject, £3 38.

124

The

Advertisements.

{CHEMICAL NEWS, Sept. 15, 1876.

'he London Hospital and Medical College. Royal School of Mines. Department of

[blocks in formation]

The next Winter Session will commence on Monday, October 2nd, when the Introductory Lecture will be given by Dr. Andrew Clark, Senior Physician to the Hospital.

The Perpetual Fee to Lectures and Hospital Practice, with two years' Practical Anatomy, is 90 guineas if paid in one sum, or 100 guineas if paid by three instalments. Special entries can be made to Lectures or Practice. The Hospital contains about 800 beds. The in-patients during 1875 were 5804, and the out-patients 40,717.

1, 2. Two Entrance Science Scholarships, value £60 and £40. 3, 4. And Two Burton Scholarships, value £30 and £20, will be offered for competition at the end of September. Entries for the above must be made on or before the 20th September. 5. A Scholarship, value £20, in Human Anatomy, for first year 6. A Scholarship, value £25, in Anatomy, Physiology, and Chemistry, for first and second year students.

Students.

7. A Hospital Scholarship, value £20, for Clinical Medicine. 8. A Hospital Scholarship, value £20, for Clinical Surgery. 9. A Hospital Scholarship, value £20, for Clinical Obstetrics. A Prize of £5 to the student who has attended most Midwifery cases during the preceding twelve months.

The Duckworth Nelson Prize, value £10, for Practical Medicine and Surgery (Biennial).

Money Prizes to the value of £60 given annually by the House Committee for zeal in Dressing Out-Patients and knowledge of Minor Surgery.

For particulars as to appointments, &c., see the Prospectus, which will be forwarded on application to the Secretary, Turner Street, Mile End, E.

Greatly increased facilities are now offered by adjacent railways and

SCIENCE AND ART.

During the Twenty-sixth Session, 1876-77, which will commence on the 2nd of October, the following COURSES of LECTURES and PRACTICAL DEMONSTRATIONS will be given:

1. Chemistry. By E. Frankland, Ph.D., F.R.S.

2. Metallurgy. By John Percy, M.D., F.R.S.

3. Natural History. By T. H. Huxley, LL.D., F.R.S.

4. Mineralogy. By Warington W. Smyth, M.A., F.R.S., 5. Mining.

6. Geology. By John W. Judd.

Chairman.

7. Applied Mechanics. By T. M. Goodeve, M.A.

8. Physics. By Frederick Guthrie, Ph.D., F.R.S.

9. Mechanical Drawing. By Rev. J. H. Edgar, M.A.

The Lecture Fees for Students desirous of becoming Associates are £30 in one sum, on entrance, or two annual payments of £20, exclusive of the Laboratories.

Tickets to separate Courses of Lectures are issued at £3 and £4 each.

Officers in the Queen's Service, Her Majesty's Consuls, Acting Mining Agents, and Managers may obtain Tickets at reduced prices. Science Teachers are also admitted to the Lectures at reduced fees. For a Prospectus and information apply to the Registrar, Royal School of Mines, Jermyn Street, London, S.W.

TRENHAM REEKS, Registrar.

ROYAL VETERINARY

COLLEGE.

INCORPORATED BY ROYAL CHARTER.
WINTER SESSION, 1876-7.

The Winter Sessional Course of Instruction will commence on MONDAY, OCTOBER 2.

The chair will be taken by R. W. Gaussen, Esq., and the Introductory Address delivered by Professor Pritchard, at i p.m.

Lectures, Clinical and Pathological Demonstrations, and General Instruction are given on Pathology and Diseases of the Horse and other Domesticated Animals, including Epizootics, Parasites, and Parasitic Affections; also on Anatomy, Physiology, Histology, Che mistry (General and Practical), Materia Medica, Toxicology, Botany, Therapeutics and Pharmacy, Hospital Practice, Obstetrics, Operative Surgery, the Principles and Practice of Shoeing, &c.

Students are required to attend two Summer and three Winter Sessions before being eligible for examination for the diploma of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons.

A Scholarship of £25 per annum, tenable for two years, will be awarded at the close of the Summer Session of 1877.

Annual Exhibitions, Gold and Silver Collegiate Medals, a Cattle Pathology Silver Medal, and Certificate of Merit will also be awarded in addition to the Coleman Prize Medals. Class Prizes will be given in each division of the student's studies. Certificates of Distinction will likewise be conferred on students who pass a superior examination for the Diploma of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons. Graduates who obtain Certificates of Distinction will be entitled to compete for the Prizes offered by the Royal Agricultural Society for proficiency of knowledge of the diseases affecting Cattle, Sheep, and Pigs. The Prizes consist of a Gold Medal and £20, Silver Medal and £10, and a Bronze Medal and £5.

College Entrance Fee 25 Gs., the payment of which confers the right of attendance on all the Lectures and Collegiate Instructions, with the exception of Practical Chemistry.

The Matricular Examination will be held on the 30th of September, at 10 a.m. Fee £1 Is. Candidates for the Scholarship, as well as those who select any of the voluntary subjects as an addition to the obligatory ones, are requested to inform the Principal of their intention, and to name the subjects at least a week previously to the Examination.

A Prospectus containing the Regulations of the College, and copies of the Matriculation Examination Papers set last Session will be forwarded on application.

August, 1876.

JAMES B. SIMONDS, Principal.

tramways for rapid transit from the neighbourhood of the Hospital to BERNERS COLLEGE of CHEMISTRY.

of The East Railway Company Station is directly opposite the Hospital. Lodgings can be obtained in healthy localities in the immediate vicinity of the Hospital, at a very reasonable charge.

[blocks in formation]

EXPERIMENTAL MILITARY and NAVAL SCIENCES, under the direction of Professor E. V. GARDNER, F.E.S., &c. of the late Royal Polytechnic Institution and the Royal Naval College. The Laboratory and Class Rooms are open from 11 to 5 a.m. and from 7 to 10 p.m.daily.

Especial facilities for persons preparing for Government and other examinations.

Private Pupils will find every convenience.

Analyses, Assays, and Practical Investigations connected with Patents, &c.,conducted.

UN

For prospectus, &c., apply to Prof. E. V. G., 44, Berners-street, W
NIVERSITY OF DURHAM COLLEGE
OF PHYSICAL SCIENCE, NEWCASTLE-ON-TYNE.
Sixth Session.

The Examinations for Admission and for Exhibitions will commence on MONDAY, the 2nd OCTOBER. Three Exhibitions of the value of £15 each will be awarded to entering students who show sufficient merit in the above Examinations. Candidates for these Exhibitions must send in their names to the Secretary on or before Saturday, the 23rd September.

Prospectus and conditions to be had on application.

THEO. WOOD BUNNING, Secretary.

CHEMICAL NEWS, Sept. 22, 1876.

Chemical Treatment of Town Excreta.

[ocr errors]

125

THE CHEMICAL NEWS. powerful odour of the fresh fæces was rapidly destroyed,

[blocks in formation]

PRESENT methods of dealing chemically with sewage resolve themselves into, first, treatment with lime; secondly, treatment with metallic oxides or salts; and, thirdly, treatment with carbon.

In reference to the lime process chemists are familiar with the literature upon the subject.

The second method, viz., the use of a metallic oxide or salt has certain advantages when the precipitant can be obtained cheaply and the sewage to be dealt with is largely contaminated with refuse from dye-works, as is the case at Leeds and Coventry. Subsulphate of alumina has been used in such cases. The third method of dealing with sewage, viz., by the agency of carbon, appears to me to be most generally useful, for whilst possessing the power of abstracting noxious matter from the sewage in at least as great a ratio as any chemical that can be used, the carbonaceous deposits are not liable to subsequent noxious decomposition, and the manurial value of the mud is not interfered with. In practice carbon is used in processes such as the ABC, where alum is an essential part of the system.

The efficiency of carbon for these purposes is doubtless dependent upon its being in a fine state of division, and in practice a cheap form of carbon, suitable for deodorising, has not been by any means easy to get. Common coke, peat charcoal, carbonised street sweepings, and, as proposed by Mr. Stanford, carbonised excreta, have been proposed or actually used, but all these forms of charcoal require expensive and cumbrous plant in the form of retorts, and condensing arrangements for vapours evolved in the distillation, and involve a large consumption of fuel for carbonisation, so that I have never known of any kind of charcoal being obtainable under at least 10s. per ton prime cost, the market price being generally from 20s. to 6os. per ton. My attention has been directed to a waste product produced largely-in fact, to the extent of 500,000 or 600,000 tons annually in Scotland alone. I mean the carbonised shale after removal from the retorts of our mineral oil works. The quantity of fixed carbon it contains ranges about 10 per cent, and its state of division no doubt is similar to that contained in boneblack, the carbon in the former case being associated with silicates of alum, lime, and magnesia, and, in the la ter, with phosphates and carbonates of lime. An analysis of the mineral constituents shows the following composition, the material having been dried at 60° F. :—

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small]

with an equal weight of carbonised shale powder. The the mixture became odourless, and I preserved samples in partially closed wide-mouthed bottles. During 10 days and at a temperature of 60° F. no fœtid or unpleasant smell was noticeable, and the mass being somewhat pasty I mixed it with more shale powder, so as to bring it to a pulverulent state suitable for sowing by hand as a manure, and the sample has been kept until this date without emitting the least smell of organic putrefaction. Subsequently to this and in the month of June, 1875, experiments were made with the object of comparing its action with that of bone and wood charcoal. The same mixture of fæces and urine was used. As the general result of these experiments it was found that whether animal charcoal or carbonised shale were used the proportion of one part of carbon to two of excrementitious matter was insufficient to prevent a slight putrefactive smell, after the lapse of two or three weeks, but that equal parts of excrementitious matter and carbon formed a permanently odourless mass, whether animal charcoal or carbonised oil shale were used. It appears therefore that for deodorising excreta carbonised oil shale requires to be used in the same proportion as excreta charcoal is recommended to be used by Mr. E. C. C. Stanford. Experiments were also made with urine alone, in the proportion of one part of carbonised shale powder to 4 of urine. The latter was gradually changed into a liquid smelling purely of ammonia and without the slightest putrefactive smell although it was kept some weeks.

In order to make experiments with sewage the City Statute Labour Trust of Glasgow supplied sewage collected from the following points:

1. Sandyfaulds Street, Caledonia Road; 2. Duke Street; 3. Great Hamilton Street; 4. Gloucester Street; 5. Sauchiehall Street.

These samples were mixed so as to get a fair average, and coming from water-closet districts in dry weather, the smell was most offensive. It was divided into two portions. The first portion was agitated for ten minutes with finely divided bone-black in the proportion of 100 grains to the gallon, and the mixture was then thrown being collected. The second portion was agitated with a upon a funnel partially plugged with sponge, the liquid similar quantity of carbonised oil shale in the same proportion and manner. Both these filtrates came through deodorised, and have kept sweet to the present time. Examined some months afterwards after being kept in closely stoppered bottles, the unfiltered sample contained 4 210 free ammonia in 100,000 parts, and the sample, filtered through the carbonised shale, contained 0:428 free ammonia.

In regard to albuminoid ammonia the unfiltered sample contained 0.333 part and the filtered sample o 285 part. In reference to the adaptability of the material for the drycloset system, the ease with which it can be reduced to a soft charcoally powder is a great recommendation. Since these laboratory experiments have been made they have been confirmed by experiments on a large scale, and more particularly with the refuse from the water-closets and surgical wards of the Glasgow Royal Infirmary-the excrementitious matter from which is about as repulsive as any that can be met with. It is semi-liquid in character, and an experiment conducted by the author in conjunction with the medical superintendent proved that on mixing about 2 cwts. of this material with the same weight of the carbonised shale, it was, in the course of a few minutes, completely deodorised.

Experiments have been also made by the Sanitary Inspector of the City of Glasgow. His report to the Police Board, dated January of the present year, includes description of experiments made with about 7 tons of the ground material in three of the public privies of the city, and extending over a period of fifty-seven days.

The Sanitary Inspector fully endorsed the conclusions arrived at by the author as to the powerful deodorising

126

Chemical Treatment of Town Excreta.

{CHEMICAL N765,

Sept. 22, 1876.

effect of the substance, and strongly recommended its | solid matters to subside, and afterwards filtering the preregular use by the city authorities.

Glasgow public conveniences are, however, most of them on Macfarlane's water-trough system, and the difficulty of adapting self-acting mechanical arrangements to them prevented the adoption of a dry method, as also the fact that a Royal Commission on the subject of dealing with Glasgow sewage was then sitting.

In treating sewage with the material upward filtration might be resorted to, or the carbonised shale might be employed in constructing, upon the sandy foreshores of the river, filters to be eventually converted to soil, or the material could be used as an adjunct to earth intermittent filters, or as an ordinary filter, combined, if necessary, with depositing tanks.

Perhaps the best plan of utilising it would be the latter, the material being ground to a fine powder, and poured into the main sewer about 100 yards from the outfall, so as to establish thorough mechanical agitation; the mixture could then be allowed to deposit in tanks, and the clear overflow filtered through a filter of the same material in a coarsely powdered or crushed state.

It will be in the recollection of members of this Section that our distinguished past President, Sir John Hawkshaw, has been acting as Royal Commissioner appointed to inquire as to the purification of the River Clyde.

The report of the Royal Commissioner, which deals with the whole valley of the Clyde, recommends, however, chemical processes or irrigation for some of the smaller towns of the valley only, and goes on to express an opinion that he can see no other course in dealing with the sewage of Glasgow than running it to the sea with engineering works, estimated to cost 24 millions sterling, and including a tunnel 30 or 40 miles long.

The Royal Commissioner, however, appears conscious himself that chemical science may eventually solve the difficulty, for towards the close of his report he remarks these engineering works would not be thrown away by improved methods of treatment at the outfall. If chemical science can suggest a means of lessening the enormous expenditure of two and a half millions Sir John appears to think necessary, I feel no doubt the Royal Commissioner would be gratified. The tunnel scheme is a suggestion: the absolute recommendations of the Royal Commissioner being statesmanlike proposals for organising a Board of Sanitary Commissioners for the Clyde Valley, with certain definite powers, leaving it with local townships to carry out any particular plan of purification that may be agreed upon and approved of by the central authority he proposes

to create.

Sir John Hawkshaw, in the course of his enquiry, investigated the chemical processes in use in other towns, and discussed with much care the problem of dealing with the sewage of the second city of the Empire, which amounts in dry weather to 48,000,000 gallons daily."

Whilst approving of dry-closet systems in regard to public works and in particular circumstances, the Royal Commissioner does not see how such a revolution can be effected in large towns as the abolition of water-closets.

After dismissing irrigation as impracticable from want of suitable land, and a strong objection to making experiments with ratepayers' money in farming, the report enters into the discussion of chemical processes versus gravitation to the sea.

The arguments Sir John uses, independently of any bearing they have on the author's proposals, are of interest generally in regard to the question of dealing with the sewage of any large city, and I may also add particularly to irrigationists, in respect to the dealing with the sewage mud, which it is impossible to deliver over square miles of land by the pipes employed in irrigation.

The Royal Commissioner uses these words-"By the addition of suitable deodorising and precipitating agents, such as alum, clay, lime, and charcoal, then allowing the * Bateman and Bazalgette's" Report," 1868. Sir John Hawkshaw's "Report," 1876.

pared liquid through prepared filters to be used inter-
mittently, I believe that the whole of the sewage of the
City of Glasgow might be discharged into the Clyde
without causing a nuisance to the neighbourhood."
The adoption of a chemical method is condemned for
the following reasons:-

(1.) It is argued that, assuming the daily flow of Glas-
gow sewage to be 48,000,000 gallons, the solid
matters in the sewage suitable for carting would
probably amount to 186,000 tons per annum.
(2.) That the lime used for precipitation would probably
increase the weight of this mud to between
400,000 or 500,000 tons annually.

(3.) That on information received from Mr. J. B. Lawes
and Mr. Caird, that the annual consumption of
artificial manures in the United Kingdom does
not exceed 800,000 tons, he does not see how
Glasgow could dispose of 400,000 or 500,000

tons.

(4.) That judging from the balance-sheets of the sewage works at Leeds the cost of dealing with Glasgow sewage chemically would be £80,000 per annum Now in respect to the first argument. Glasgow sewage was analysed by the Rivers Pollution Commissioners under the superintendence of Dr. Frankland in 1870 ("Riv. Poll. Com.," Fourth Report, p. 26). It contains, in round numbers, 142 parts of solids per 100,000, which is equal to about 100 grs. per gallon. Again, Dr. Hofmann, in his Report on London Sewage, estimates its average composition as 100 grs. solids per gallon. Glasgow sewage, owing to the plentiful rainfall and abundant water-supply from Loch Katrine, is weaker than that of other towns; so that it is impossible that 48,000,000 gallons per day of sewage could give more than 100,000 tons per annum of solids, supposing the effluent be discharged as pure as distilled water.

From this quantity must be deducted the soluble saline constituents, reducing it, say, four-tenths, or to 60,000 tons; and there must be added the moisture contained in artificial manures, say 25 per cent, which gives us as the probable correct figure 80,000 tons as the annual probable quantity of solids separable from Glasgow sewage in the form of manure.

That this figure is correct is confirmed by Prof Way'st report on the sewage of towns, which would bring out the quantity 91,000 tons. Mr. J. B. Lawes's estimates would bring out 89,000 tons according to the ratio of 2 to 3 lbs. solids per ton. Finally, the experiments of Mr. Keatest at Crossness showed that 142 tons of prepared manure was obtained from 11,672,751 gallons of London sewage; 61 tons representing the mud precipitated from the sewage. This would indicate 80,000 tons per annum for Glasgow sewage, which I assume to be correct in place of the 186,000 tons assumed by Sir John Hawkshaw.

In regard to the next argument of the Royal Commissioner, that the solids would be more than doubled by the lime process, this is difficult to see, as lime is only added as a fraction of the solids. It may be correct as regards carbon processes, but even then the annual production of manure would be 160,000 to 200,000 tons instead of the 400,000 or 500,000 tons estimated by Sir John.

In reference to the third argument that the manure could not be disposed of. If sewage mud be classed with artificial manures of several pounds value, which appears to be what Messrs. Lawes and Caird include in their figures of 700,000 or 800,000 tons annual consumption of the United Kingdom, then I agree with the Royal Commissioner. But this is not the case. Sewage mud manure has only a few shillings value, and should be compared with city street sweepings manure, of which the City of * Hofmann and Witt," Report on London Sewage ;" also "Corfield on Sewage," 179 to 184 inclusive.

+ See Reports of Sewage of Towns Commissioners."

See Mr. Keates's "Report to the Metropolitan Board of Works."

« PoprzedniaDalej »